Professor of politics Judith Brett offers many reasons to be cheerful about Australia.
Despite there being much despondency about contemporary Australian politics, Judith Brett finds plenty to be cheerful about. In From Secret Ballot to Democracy Sausage,
Brett argues that the politicians, bureaucrats and citizens who
developed our voting system deserve as much recognition in the popular
imagination as the soldiers who fought at Gallipoli. A big claim, but
worth paying attention to.
The
story begins with the first parliamentary elections in 1843, held at
Port Jackson (now Sydney). Elections in those days were rowdy affairs,
with bribery and bullying the order of the day. An early innovation was
the secret ballot, leading to a more orderly and secure vote. When
concerns that first-past-the-post voting could lead to a candidate
winning with a minority vote, a system of preferential voting was
introduced. It was a woman, Catherine Helen Spence, who was at the
forefront of this reform. By 1924, with the introduction of compulsory
voting, Australia's modern voting system was pretty much in place.
Compulsory
voting is the jewel in the crown of Australia's electoral culture, rare
among modern democracies, one that tempers extremism as politicians
must pitch policies to all voters – whether poor or rich, migrant or
native born. Brett also argues that without compulsory voting, the
disaffected would drop out of the process altogether. Compulsion makes
them park their vote somewhere, allowing new voices to appear – Cliver
Palmer, One Nation, the Greens. None perfect, by any means, but at least
offering a way for the disenfranchised to let off steam.
The
record is not perfect, however. There are dark stains on our voting
history, namely the treatment of our first peoples. The aboriginal vote
was by and large suppressed; rights were legislated away. Some
aborigines, in some states, could vote, but it was always made
difficult. Many worried about giving the vote to aboriginal people due
to their dominant numbers. Shamefully it took until 1983, under the
Hawke government, for full equality to be achieved when voting was made
compulsory for indigenous Australians.
The
last few chapters examine recent votes, with special attention paid to
the same sex marriage survey. Brett is quite critical of this survey (it
wasn't technically a vote) and its unusual process. The eight week
voting period was far too long, the process wasn't secret, the postal
surveys were easily tampered with and the method of announcement, by the
head of the Australian Bureau of Statistics who conducted the survey,
unorthodox.
This
is a terrific read. A pithy and engaging history of how Australia
developed a first class voting system that has saved us from much
division and extremism. A celebration of what Australia does best: fair,
progressive, inclusive elections.
From Secret Ballot to Democracy Sausage: How Australia Got Compulsory Voting, by Judith Brett. Text $29.99
No comments:
Post a Comment